Quantcast

Ark-la-tex resident scammed by Home Warranty Company - KTBS.com - Shreveport, LA News, Weather and Sports

Ark-la-tex resident scammed by Home Warranty Company

Posted: Updated:

Buying and selling a home are no small tasks.  And unfortunately, there are scammers out there looking to cash in on the often complicated process.  First time home buyers Michelle Bogan and her husband thought they'd found a good deal when they bought a house with a home warranty included for the first year.  But right after moving in, Bogan found the company behind the warranty wasn't following through - and as it turns out - the company isn't even supposed to selling policies in the state of Louisiana.

During one of our warmer days in December, the Bogan's A/C unit went out.  She knew it was covered, so she called "Sensible Home Warranty." "They sent someone out, he looked at it, said it was one problem, turns out it wasn't that it was the compressor, and he would have to get with underwriting at Sensible to get it fixed. Well, they went back and forth with us for a few months saying they needed maintenance records or else they wouldn't fix it."

The warranty contract specifically says "in the event one of the major systems...requires replacement...Maintenance records are required.  In the event no maintenance can be had (ie. New home purchase) a copy of the home inspection must be furnished to sensible home warranty."  Bogan says she gave them the inspection report right away.  And she even had the previous owner provide some earlier maintenance reports. 

"I've contacted them several times," she says, "they just keep saying they want maintenance records, and the past couple times I've contacted them saying we reported them to the Better Business Bureau, they haven't even responded."  Bogan said according to her correspondence with the BBB, "Sensible Home Warranty" hasn't responded to the BBB either, once her formal complaint was filed.

Unfortunately, the Bogan's aren't the only people fed up with this company. There are over 1,300 complaints filed against them on the BBB's web site.  "Sensible Home Warranty" has an "F" letter grade with the BBB.  In Oklahoma, the Insurance Commissioner revoked their license.  And, "Cease and Desist" orders have been sent by Utah, Washington, and Louisiana.

"They are not licensed in our state," says Louisiana Insurance Commissioner James Donelon, "They're authorized in other states...to do home warranty business but they're not authorized in Louisiana, even though they were selling such contracts in our state.  We issued a "Cease and Desist" order to them and told them to stop doing business in our state."  That "Cease and Desist" order was sent back in January of 2013, almost a year before Bogan's policy went into effect. 

So ultimately, you the consumer need to make sure you don't wind up like the Bogan's.  "Do your research, do you due diligence, look at it from every angle, check with other people, look at reviews online," says Bogan.  And you can't take the companies word for it since "Sensible Home Warranty" claims it's a provider that "truly cares for its policy holders" and is "guaranteed to save you money and give you a peace of mind."  In a letter sent to the Bogan's when their policy started "Sensible Home Warranty" thanked them for their business, assuring them their choice was a solid one.

"I feel like we were really betrayed and lied to by the insurance company," says Bogan, "We're going to have to get our whole unit replaced because our air conditioner is old...we're going to go in debt about $8,000."

The local contractor sent out is "V Force Repairs."  We spoke with them about the bogan's situation.   They say they told "Sensible Home Warranty" what needed to be fixed at the bogan's house.  But they can't perform the repairs because they've never heard back from the company has yet to authorize the repair. And "V Force Repairs" claims they're still waiting to be paid by Sensible for work they've done for other warranty clients.  

When choosing a home warranty company, both the Department of Insurance and Better Business Bureau are good resources.However, if you have a complaint with an insurance company, make sure you file a complaint with the insurance commissioner.   They can fine, reprimand, and regulate the insurance industry, unlike the BBB.

If you want to file a complaint with the DOI, Donelon says this is how it is handled: "We submit it to the company, and we take complaints either verbally, online or even over the phone...And they under statue have X number of days to reply to the complaint. They typically ask for an extension of time in which to investigate the matter and submit their answer.  Sometimes we grant that extension, I'd even say most times we grant it for an additional 30 days, maybe 15, and when the response comes in we evaluate that and make a determination as to whether or not the company was at fault.  We keep a tally by company, by agent, by adjustor, whoever we regulate, of complaints against that particular individual or company." 

If you need to report insurance fraud click here

If you need to file an insurance complaint click here.

  • Crime StoppersMore>>

  • Kenneth Willis' capital murder case delayed, state will assign new counsel

    Kenneth Willis' capital murder case delayed, state will assign new counsel

    Monday, September 15 2014 8:01 PM EDT2014-09-16 00:01:38 GMT
    Kenneth Willis (Photo: Caddo Parish Sheriff's Office)Kenneth Willis (Photo: Caddo Parish Sheriff's Office)
    Less than a month before his jury selection scheduled to start, Judge Brady O'Callaghan pushed back accused child killer Kennth Willis's trial.
    Less than a month before his jury selection scheduled to start, Judge Brady O'Callaghan pushed back accused child killer Kennth Willis's trial.
  • Tattoo could lead to arrest in Shreveport UPS break-in

    Tattoo could lead to arrest in Shreveport UPS break-in

    Monday, September 15 2014 6:37 PM EDT2014-09-15 22:37:47 GMT
    Crimestoppers has cash for clues to a crime that was caught on camera.It happened September 6th at the UPS store in the 2500 block of Bert Kouns in Shreveport.
    Crimestoppers has cash for clues to a crime that was caught on camera.It happened September 6th at the UPS store in the 2500 block of Bert Kouns in Shreveport.
  • Names of Shreveport Police officers in shooting incident released

    Names of Shreveport Police officers in shooting incident released

    Monday, September 15 2014 6:18 PM EDT2014-09-15 22:18:51 GMT
    The Shreveport Police Department has released the names of two officers involved in a shooting incident Saturday evening in north Shreveport.On September 14, Officers Barbara Kendrick and Marie Jones were placed on routine paid administrative leave by Chief of Police Willie Shaw pending an investigation into a shooting incident which occurred at approximately 10:20 p.m. on September 13.During the incident, Officers Kendrick and Jones were actively searching the grounds of an apartment complex...
    The Shreveport Police Department has released the names of two officers involved in a shooting incident Saturday evening in north Shreveport.On September 14, Officers Barbara Kendrick and Marie Jones were placed on routine paid administrative leave by Chief of Police Willie Shaw pending an investigation into a shooting incident which occurred at approximately 10:20 p.m. on September 13.During the incident, Officers Kendrick and Jones were actively searching the grounds of an apartment complex...
  • KTBS 3 InvestigatesMore>>

  • Shreveport mayoral candidate "doubled dipped" thousands of dollars

    Shreveport mayoral candidate "doubled dipped" thousands of dollars

    Monday, September 15 2014 2:00 PM EDT2014-09-15 18:00:14 GMT
    There's more "double dipping" trouble for a candidate for Shreveport mayor.Back in May, we showed you how Patrick Williams explained away one questionable hotel reimbursement. But our research has turned up a pattern of double dipping by the state representative. That is, he got paid back twice for the same expense.Our research from just the year 2012 shows that williams double dipped 45 times for a total amount of $4,021.88. He was paid back once by the state of Louisiana -- the taxpayers --...
    There's more "double dipping" trouble for a candidate for Shreveport mayor.Back in May, we showed you how Patrick Williams explained away one questionable hotel reimbursement. But our research has turned up a pattern of double dipping by the state representative. That is, he got paid back twice for the same expense.Our research from just the year 2012 shows that williams double dipped 45 times for a total amount of $4,021.88. He was paid back once by the state of Louisiana -- the taxpayers --...
  • Closing a "fatal gap:" How Louisiana is doing 9 months after enhanced background check laws go into effect

    Closing a "fatal gap:" How Louisiana is doing 9 months after enhanced background check laws go into effect

    Monday, September 8 2014 12:16 PM EDT2014-09-08 16:16:54 GMT
    Tuesday, September 9 2014 6:00 PM EDT2014-09-09 22:00:26 GMT
    About one year ago, KTBS brought you a startling investigation into federal background checks for firearm purchases. Background checks are supposed to weed out felons and mental defectives. But Louisiana had reported zero mental defectives to the FBI's background check system, making us one of the worst states for keeping guns out of the hands of the mentally ill. Because of that, lawmakers passed laws to fix these broken background checks. Until this law went into effect, someone could walk...
    About one year ago, KTBS brought you a startling investigation into federal background checks for firearm purchases. Background checks are supposed to weed out felons and mental defectives. But Louisiana had reported zero mental defectives to the FBI's background check system, making us one of the worst states for keeping guns out of the hands of the mentally ill. Because of that, lawmakers passed laws to fix these broken background checks. Until this law went into effect, someone could walk...
  • The Military’s Search for 1 little boy ends in Shreveport: "Hope you make it." ---- Gavin

    The Military’s Search for 1 little boy ends in Shreveport: "Hope you make it." ---- Gavin

    Thursday, August 21 2014 10:31 AM EDT2014-08-21 14:31:10 GMT
    Saturday, September 6 2014 5:02 PM EDT2014-09-06 21:02:06 GMT
    © "Hope you make it." ----Gavin© "Hope you make it." ----Gavin
     Airmen and soldiers serving in Afghanistan found laughter in difficult times, all courtesy of 4 little words in a letter from a school child – “Hope you make it. – Gavin” The troops wanted to meet the young man who inspired them so much.
     Airmen and soldiers serving in Afghanistan found laughter in difficult times, all courtesy of 4 little words in a letter from a school child – “Hope you make it. – Gavin” The troops wanted to meet the young man who inspired them so much.
  • ArkLaTex SlideshowsMore>>

  • Just for fun: Look at 2013 Pumpkins and Punkins #3harvest

    Just for fun: Look at 2013 Pumpkins and Punkins #3harvest

    Saturday, September 13 2014 11:23 PM EDT2014-09-14 03:23:09 GMT
    © A look back at Fall 2013© A look back at Fall 2013
    Thank you to all of our viewers who sent us your pumpkins and punkins pictures. #3harvest
    Thank you to all of our viewers who sent us your pumpkins and punkins pictures. #3harvest
  • KTBS Friday Football Fever 9-12-14

    KTBS Friday Football Fever 9-12-14

    Saturday, September 13 2014 6:22 PM EDT2014-09-13 22:22:46 GMT
    KTBS Friday Football Fever is in full swing, Check it out
    KTBS Friday Football Fever is in full swing, Check it out
  • North LA Criminal Justice Academy graduates 15

    North LA Criminal Justice Academy graduates 15

    Friday, May 23 2014 5:03 PM EDT2014-05-23 21:03:25 GMT
    Friday, May 23 2014 5:03 PM EDT2014-05-23 21:03:25 GMT
    Photy by: Josh Cagle, Bossier Parish Sheriff's OfficePhoty by: Josh Cagle, Bossier Parish Sheriff's Office
    Fifteen recruits from four agencies became certified P.O.S.T. (Peace Officer Standards and Training) law enforcement officers during the graduation of Class 011 from North Louisiana Criminal Justice Academy May 23.
    Fifteen recruits from four agencies became certified P.O.S.T. (Peace Officer Standards and Training) law enforcement officers during the graduation of Class 011 from North Louisiana Criminal Justice Academy May 23.
  • Assignment EducationMore>>

  • Fighting School Violence

    Fighting School Violence

    Monday, September 8 2014 2:14 PM EDT2014-09-08 18:14:17 GMT
    Friday, September 12 2014 11:33 PM EDT2014-09-13 03:33:54 GMT
    Although school violence at any level is unacceptable, school leaders say schools are not more dangerous now than they where a decade Ago.One recent tragedy of an in school homicide has put a spotlight on violent behavior in students to the public's attention.
    Although school violence at any level is unacceptable, school leaders say schools are not more dangerous now than they where a decade Ago.One recent tragedy of an in school homicide has put a spotlight on violent behavior in students to the public's attention.
  • Interim member chosen for vacant seat on Caddo School Board

    Interim member chosen for vacant seat on Caddo School Board

    Friday, September 12 2014 6:14 PM EDT2014-09-12 22:14:32 GMT
    Dorothy Nell Warren Fisher is sworn in as interim Caddo Parish School Board member.Dorothy Nell Warren Fisher is sworn in as interim Caddo Parish School Board member.
    Caddo School Board members have chosen an interim member to fill the seat left vacant following the death of Lillian Priest of district seven.The board just wrapped up interviews with the seven candidates and they selected Dorothy Nell Warren Fisher.
    Caddo School Board members have chosen an interim member to fill the seat left vacant following the death of Lillian Priest of district seven.The board just wrapped up interviews with the seven candidates and they selected Dorothy Nell Warren Fisher.
  • Louisiana Tech welcomes largest freshman class since new admission standards put in place

    Louisiana Tech welcomes largest freshman class since new admission standards put in place

    Thursday, September 11 2014 2:55 PM EDT2014-09-11 18:55:30 GMT
    More than 1,200 students were estimated to attend Louisiana Tech's Freshman Convocation on September 3, 2014. They did not all fit in Howard Auditorium. A couple hundred had to watch via a video feed in the Student Union.More than 1,200 students were estimated to attend Louisiana Tech's Freshman Convocation on September 3, 2014. They did not all fit in Howard Auditorium. A couple hundred had to watch via a video feed in the Student Union.

    “We really won't know until the 9th class day, but we expect about a 15 percent increase in the size of our freshman class,” said Dr. James King, vice president of the University.

    “We really won't know until the 9th class day, but we expect about a 15 percent increase in the size of our freshman class,” said Dr. James King, vice president of the University.

  • KTBS 3 News Tips

    Send your news tip or story idea to the KTBS 3 Newsroom.  Enter your email address below to get started.

    * denotes required fields
    We're sorry, but only one entry is allowed per person.
    Thank you for your continued interest.

    Thank you for your submission to KTBS 3 News.  A member of our staff may contact you for more information.

Share Your Images
Powered by WorldNow
    Powered by WorldNow
    All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 Worldnow and KTBS. All Rights Reserved. For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service.
    Advertising | EEO Public File | KTBS 3 Public File | KPXJ 21 Public File